How to Hire an SEO Manager: A Comprehensive Guide for Recruiters

Hiring an SEO Manager is a critical decision for companies looking to boost their online visibility and drive organic traffic. Many organizations underestimate the complexity of this role, often focusing solely on technical skills while overlooking the strategic and leadership qualities required. A successful SEO Manager needs to balance technical expertise with a deep understanding of marketing principles and the ability to align SEO strategies with broader business goals.

This guide provides recruiters and hiring managers with actionable insights on how to identify, evaluate, and hire top SEO talent. We'll cover everything from crafting an effective job description to conducting skill assessments and structuring interviews. For a deeper dive into specific SEO skills to look for, check out our comprehensive list of SEO Manager skills.

Table of contents

Why Hire an SEO Manager?

An SEO Manager can be a game-changer for your online presence. If your website traffic is stagnant or declining, or if you're struggling to rank for important keywords, it's time to consider bringing an SEO expert on board.

SEO Managers can help by:

• Developing and implementing comprehensive SEO strategies
• Optimizing website content and structure
• Analyzing and reporting on SEO performance metrics

Before hiring full-time, assess your long-term SEO needs and budget. For smaller projects or to test the waters, you might start with a consultant or freelance SEO specialist. As your SEO demands grow, transitioning to a full-time SEO Manager becomes more cost-effective and strategically beneficial.

What Does an SEO Manager Do?

An SEO Manager leads a company's search engine optimization efforts to improve website visibility and organic traffic. They develop and implement strategies to boost search rankings, analyze website performance, and stay updated on the latest SEO trends and algorithm changes.

The day-to-day responsibilities of an SEO Manager include:

• Conducting keyword research and optimizing website content
• Analyzing website metrics and creating performance reports
• Coordinating with content teams to ensure SEO-friendly content creation
• Managing link building campaigns and improving site architecture
• Collaborating with web developers to implement technical SEO improvements
• Staying informed about digital marketing trends and adjusting strategies accordingly
• Training team members and stakeholders on SEO best practices

Skills and qualifications to look for in an SEO Manager

Hiring an SEO Manager can be a bit tricky due to the fast-evolving nature of SEO and digital marketing. Recruiters often face challenges in defining the right candidate profile because the requirements can vary significantly depending on company-specific needs. It's crucial to draw a clear line between what is required and what is preferred for your business context.

When building the ideal candidate profile, consider skills like a Bachelor's degree in Marketing, Business, or related fields, and at least 3 years of experience in SEO. Candidates should have a proven track record in creating successful SEO strategies and campaigns. Proficiency in tools like Google Analytics, SEMrush, and Moz is a must.

Preferred qualifications might include experience with HTML/CSS, understanding content management systems like WordPress, and familiarity with PPC campaigns. Certification in Google Analytics or similar platforms can be beneficial. Experience in fast-paced and collaborative environments is also preferred.

For recruiters looking to screen candidates efficiently, utilizing pre-employment testing can be a strategic advantage. It helps in assessing the candidate's practical skills, ensuring they align with your company's specific needs.

How to Write an SEO Manager Job Description

Once you have a candidate profile ready, the next step is to capture that information in the job description to attract the right candidates. A well-crafted job description is a key tool in your hiring process.

• Highlight key responsibilities and impact: Clearly outline the responsibilities of the SEO Manager, such as developing and implementing SEO strategies, analyzing data, and optimizing website content. By specifying how their work will enhance your company's online presence, you attract candidates eager to make a difference.

• Balance technical skills with industry expertise: While listing technical skills like proficiency in SEO tools and analytics, don't forget to mention the importance of industry knowledge and experience. This ensures you attract candidates who can effectively navigate the ever-evolving landscape of search engines.

• Showcase unique selling points of your company and role: Highlight what makes your company and the role unique. Whether it's opportunities for creativity, professional growth, or working with a talented team, these aspects can make your job description stand out. For more details, refer to the SEO Manager job description.

Best Platforms to Hire SEO Managers

Once you've crafted a compelling job description for your SEO Manager role, the next step is to post it on job listing sites to attract qualified candidates. It's essential to choose platforms that align with your hiring needs, whether you're looking for full-time, part-time, or freelance talent.

LinkedIn Jobs

Ideal for posting full-time SEO Manager positions. Reaches a wide professional network and allows detailed job descriptions and company profiles.

Indeed

Versatile platform suitable for posting full-time, part-time, and contract SEO Manager roles. Offers wide reach and easy application process.

Upwork

Best for hiring freelance SEO Managers. Offers a large pool of global talent and allows for project-based or hourly contracts.

In addition to major platforms like LinkedIn Jobs, Indeed, and Upwork, there are several other excellent options. Glassdoor is a great choice for full-time roles, offering candidates insights into your company culture. If you're seeking project-based expertise, Freelancer is ideal for short-term SEO tasks. For tech-focused roles, Dice provides access to professionals with strong technical skills. FlexJobs caters to those wanting remote positions, while Toptal connects you with elite freelance SEO talent. Monster offers a versatile approach suitable for various types of roles, and AngelList Talent attracts candidates eager to work with innovative startups. Consider using remote hiring platforms that offer flexibility and convenience in reaching top talent.

Keywords to Look for in SEO Manager Resumes

Resume screening is a key step in finding the right SEO Manager. It helps you quickly identify candidates with the most relevant skills and experience before moving to interviews.

When manually screening resumes, focus on key SEO-related terms. Look for mentions of SEO strategies, technical SEO skills, and experience with popular tools like Google Analytics and SEMrush. Pay attention to quantifiable achievements in improving search rankings or organic traffic.

To streamline the process, consider using AI-powered screening tools. These can quickly scan multiple resumes for specific keywords and skills, saving you time and ensuring consistency in your initial evaluations.

Here's a sample prompt for AI-based resume screening:

TASK: Screen resumes for SEO Manager role

INPUT: Resumes

OUTPUT: For each resume, provide:
- Name
- Matching keywords
- Score (out of 10)
- Recommendation
- Shortlist (Yes, No, Maybe)

KEYWORDS:
- SEO strategy
- Technical SEO (site audits, page speed optimization)
- Analytics (Google Analytics, Search Console)
- Content optimization
- SEO tools (SEMrush, Moz, Ahrefs)
- Link building
- Keyword research

Recommended Skills Tests to Screen SEO Managers

When hiring an SEO manager, it's important to accurately assess their skills to ensure they can effectively improve your search engine visibility. Skills tests provide a reliable way to objectively evaluate a candidate's ability to drive SEO strategies and achieve results.

SEO Assessment Test: This test evaluates candidates on key SEO concepts such as keyword research, on-page and off-page optimization, and link-building strategies. It's a targeted way to ensure your candidates have the necessary skills to manage your SEO efforts. SEO Assessment Test

Digital Marketing Test: Since SEO is a vital part of digital marketing, this test assesses the broader understanding of digital marketing strategies, including social media, email marketing, and analytics. SEO managers need this knowledge to align SEO with overall marketing goals. Digital Marketing Test

Google Analytics Test: Understanding analytics is key for any SEO manager. This test checks a candidate's proficiency in Google Analytics, ensuring they can track, analyze, and report on web traffic data effectively. Google Analytics Test

Content Strategy Test: Content is king in SEO. This test evaluates candidates' ability to develop and implement successful content strategies that align with SEO goals. Content Strategy Test

Data Analysis Test: An SEO manager must handle data to make informed decisions. This test assesses their ability to interpret and analyze data, a crucial skill for optimizing SEO strategies. Data Analysis Test

How to Structure Interview Stage for Hiring SEO Managers

After candidates successfully pass skills tests, it's time to move them to the technical interview stage. While skills tests are useful for filtering out unfit candidates, they don’t necessarily pinpoint the best fit for your specific needs. A thorough interview is vital to assess the candidate's hard skills and ensure they align with your company’s objectives. Let's explore some sample interview questions tailored for an SEO Manager role.

Here are some example interview questions to consider when evaluating candidates for an SEO Manager position:

• How do you stay updated with the latest SEO trends and algorithm changes? This question assesses their commitment to continuous learning.
• Can you describe a time when you had to manage a challenging SEO project? This reveals their problem-solving capabilities and experience in handling tough situations.
• What SEO tools are you most comfortable with and why? Knowing their favored tools, like those listed in our SEO interview questions, shows their technical proficiency.
• How do you approach link-building strategies? This indicates their understanding of white hat versus black hat practices.
• What is your process for conducting an SEO audit? This checks their analytical skills and attention to detail. These questions help determine both their technical expertise and cultural fit for your team.

How much does it cost to hire an SEO Manager?

The cost of hiring an SEO Manager varies widely based on location and experience. In the United States, salaries range from $49,985 to $124,608, with an average of $84,096 annually. In India, the average salary is INR 471,060, ranging from INR 238,130 to INR 759,343. Similarly, in Canada, salaries range from CAD 38,709 to CAD 103,676, with an average of CAD 68,207. These figures highlight the importance of understanding regional salary expectations when budgeting for this role.

SEO Manager Salary United States

In the United States, the average salary for an SEO Manager is approximately $84,096 annually. Salaries can range from a minimum of $49,985 to a maximum of $124,608, depending on experience and location. For instance, SEO Managers in San Francisco may earn a median of $150,704, while those in Chicago might see a median salary around $66,989. These variations highlight the importance of regional considerations when setting salary expectations.

SEO Manager Salary United Kingdom

In the United Kingdom, the average salary for an SEO Manager ranges from £30,000 to £55,000 per year. Entry-level positions tend to start at the lower end of the scale, around £25,000, while more experienced professionals can earn upwards of £65,000 or more. Location and company size can significantly influence these figures.

SEO Manager Salary Canada

In Canada, the average salary for an SEO Manager is approximately CAD 68,207. Salaries can range from CAD 38,709 at the low end to CAD 103,676 at the high end. Factors such as location can influence pay; for instance, Toronto offers a median salary of around CAD 59,720, while SEO Managers in Vancouver might expect a median of CAD 79,723.

SEO Manager Salary India

In India, the salary for an SEO Manager can vary significantly based on location and experience. Bengaluru offers some of the highest salaries, with a range between INR 320,399 and INR 1,707,447, while Kolkata is on the lower end with salaries ranging from INR 204,686 to INR 574,621. On average, SEO Managers nationwide earn between INR 238,130 and INR 759,343, with a mean salary of INR 471,060.

Hire the Perfect SEO Manager for Your Needs

In this guide, we discussed the importance of hiring an SEO Manager, their responsibilities, and the skills and qualifications to look for. We also covered how to write a compelling job description and the best platforms to find top talent. By now, you should have a clear understanding of the key factors that contribute to hiring an outstanding SEO Manager.

The one key takeaway from this journey is to prioritize writing accurate job descriptions and using the right skills tests during the hiring process. This approach helps to ensure that the candidates you consider can truly meet your organization's needs. Consider utilizing assessments like the SEO assessment test to screen potential hires effectively and confidently.

FAQs